Bug tracking

Feed subscription: RSS or Atom.


#2982 – Be consistent in some forms
Date added: 2014-11-19 13:48:28 Type: Bug report
Status: Confirmed Priority: Minor
Affected version: trunk Milestone: 1.0RC1
Reported by: Assigned to: xbright
Why are the behaviours on the forum and in the messages different ?
In the forum, you have to click "Post a reply" (at the top of the page), then it brings you to a new page where you can post your message. You can't see the previous messages. Messages are in a top down position. The "post reply" button is misplaced here, if you want to keep the page as it is. It should be at the bottom, after all messages.
In the messages, you have everything on a single page, it doesn't bring you to a new page. Messages are in a bottom-up position.
Two completely different behaviours for similar features.

The way I see it:

There shouldn't be a second page to enter a message. Messages should be displayed in top-down way. The input field should then be below the messages.
Re: Be consistent in some forms - 2014-11-21 00:09:27
Anonymous user
(tl;dr: +1)

The behaviour should be the same when replying to a private message, or a forum post, or a bug tracker:

The posts should be older first, most recent last (and when clicking on “read the new messages” the link leads to an anchor to the last message, so we don’t have to scroll, for example).

The reply thing should be at the bottom, directly on the same page (no need to click on “write a reply” to be able to type the message).

The “insert code ABAP” should be removed, or at least made a lot more discrete
Commit reference: r579 - 2014-11-21 22:28:44
Erwan Briand
This bug was referenced by the commit r579.
xbright edited this bug - 2014-11-24 18:31:18
  • Priority changed to Minor
  • Milestone changed to 0.9.5
xbright edited this bug - 2014-11-25 19:55:59
  • Status changed to Confirmed
  • Assign to xbright
xbright edited this bug - 2018-06-29 16:51:22
  • Milestone changed to 1.0RC1
Post to this thread



Authorized (X)HTML tags: a, img, abbr, blockquote, code, ul, ol, li, h3, h4, p, br, hr, strong, em, pre, sub, sup, table, caption, thead, tr, th, tfoot, tbody, td.

Captcha security:
In order to check you are not a robot, please answer to that simple question:
Please write the last character of Viviane.